Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Quiggin's avatar

Reporting uncertainty with spurious precision is better than reporting a single number with entirely spurious precision.

Kalen's avatar

I'm nowhere near as sophisticated in these matters, but I do have to get some introductory stats students off on a footing that lets me sleep at night, and I'm always trying to emphasize something along the lines of 'every statistic is just a description of the data,' and while it lets you have a relationship with uncertainty, there's ultimately not *anything at all* you can do computationally about *just not knowing something*. You can bound your uncertainty to the extant you can bound the system, and that's easy to do on a roulette wheel and impossible to do in a world full of intelligent, bounded actors keeping secrets and/or nature doing shit behind screens you don't get to peek behind. Show me a five-nines data center and I'll show you a building that got hacked on Thursday, much less in the past billion years or whatever.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?