Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Chapman's avatar

Interesting analogy here with physicists regarding heliocentrism as a convenient fiction for more accurate prediction calculations than geocentrism, for decades after Copernicus, since heliocentrism obviously made no physical sense and violated everything we knew about everything.

(This is covered at length in Kuhn's _Copernican Revolution_, which is in many ways a better book than _Scientific Revolutions_, although also less significant.)

Expand full comment
Malome's avatar

An interesting take from a "Philosophical Psychology" viewpoint. Practising empiricists had long been dismissed for shallow "Phenomenologists" by Physicists but eventually prevailed on the sheer weight of accumulated evidence over which Perrin agonises in the 20th Century almost 200 years later.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts