4 Comments
User's avatar
Of the Esseints's avatar

Great post, I read last week Paul Romer's The Trouble with Macroeconomics (https://paulromer.net/trouble-with-macroeconomics-update/WP-Trouble.pdf for those inclined) and he illustrated the problem of dealing with a system of feedback equations with undetermined variables in a very humorous way, and elaborates upon the "theoretical" shore-ups you elide here. He also picked out that pair of Lucas quotes to beat up on, so I was wondering if you had read this article and had it in mind. Cheers.

Ben Recht's avatar

This is great. We discussed this paper in class yesterday, and I've added it to the course readings.

Viraj Nadkarni's avatar

Loved the article! Relevant classical paper here on why rules are better than the discretion of optimal control-like planning - https://www.jstor.org/stable/1830193.

Also I have a slight disagreement on the last few paras on hyperfinancialization being the cause of the GFC. I think it was a mismatch between that and not enough financialization in the monetary sector. Had there been different circulating monies based on who lent you a loan to buy a house - e.g. a dollar lent out by Lehman does not equal a dollar lent out by Goldman, then the market would have self-corrected automatically. So financialization was not the rot, but the opaqueness on top that did not allow people to judge various instruments was. In fact, the GFC is predictable given the incentives of the system -- Lehman can print money irresponsibly and the USD holder pays for it via inflation! (hyperinflation in this case, that eventually crashed). Once you get rid of these bad incentives, I think more financialization creates a more robust economy and not less.

Enon's avatar

Non-maonstream economist Steve Keen has made his work hard to link to, but some key things he has to say: Ricardo's assumptions are all false, free trade / comparitive advantage are completely debunked (as well as many other assumptions of economics such as supply and demand curves); money is created by loans, not reserves, money multiplier theory is wrong; private sector equity has to come from government debt, so paying off the debt would be a disaster; the real economy (rather than monetary metrics) is fundamentally based on energy use, efficiency can only help so much before using less energy leads to less prosperity. (My interpretation, may be inaccurate.)

His economic simulation SW, "Minsky", and his macro-accounting data-analysis SW, "Ravel", may be useful to you or your students, links in: https://substack.com/home/post/p-64907517